
If a Civil Partnership Breaks down
Statistics currently say that one in two relationships break
down. These relationships cover the whole spectrum of sexual orientation.
We can therefore expect that a fair proportion of people who register
as civil partners will seek to dissolve their civil partnership at
some time in future. Although not a ‘romantic’ view, it is worthwhile considering
the likely consequences of such dissolution. Although civil partnership is not ‘gay
marriage’, it nonetheless confers rights and responsibilities “akin
to marriage”. There is nothing in the legislation which states that way
in which the law relating to civil partners is applied will be the same as the
way in which the law relating to married couples is applied. However, it is envisaged
that the courts will follow the existing law, adapting it to fit the circumstances
of the same-sex couple’s relationship.
Dissolution Process
To formalise the separation and dissolve
the civil partnership, the process is similar to divorce. Either
of you can start the dissolution. The only ground for dissolution
is that the civil partnership has broken down irretrievably. If
you start the dissolution yourself, the only way to show that the
civil partnership has irretrievably broken down is to prove one
of four facts:
- That your civil partner has behaved in such a way that you
cannot reasonably
be expected to live with them.
- That your civil partner has deserted you for two years or more.
- That you have been separated for two years and you both agree
to the dissolution.
- That you have been separated for five
years.
If people do not want
to wait for two years, they can only base the dissolution on “behaviour” even if they both agree
to the dissolution. “Behaviour” does not need to be
violence or other extreme behaviour. A combination of other behaviour
can be sufficient. Often issues like working too much (or not working
enough), showing too much (or too little) affection, combined with
a number of other similar factors are used. Although there is no
corresponding fact to “adultery” in divorce, a relationship
or sex with another person could form the basis of an application
based on behaviour. Any behaviour you want to rely on has to have
happened in the six months before you separated or since you separated.
Court Procedure
In addition to the application for dissolution,
the “petition”,
there are other documents you or your solicitor need to prepare,
including a statement about the arrangements of any children. None
of these are of great significance for the dissolution itself though.
You can only start a civil partnership dissolution in a limited
number of courts, namely in the Principal Registry of the Family
Division in London and the county courts in Birmingham, Brighton,
Bristol, Cardiff, Chester, Exeter, Leeds, Manchester and Newcastle.
The dissolution is a two-stage process. The court will first grant
a conditional order, and later make that order final. The court
process starts when the court gets the dissolution petition, the
civil partnership certificate and other documents and the fees.
It will then allocate a number to the case, open a file and send
the papers to your civil partner, unless your solicitor asked the
court to return the papers to send them to your civil partner or
their solicitor direct.
Sending the Papers to the Other Civil
Partner
When your civil partner receives the dissolution papers, they have
to fill in a form confirming that they have received the papers
and whether or not they agree with the dissolution and return it
to the court. The court will send a copy to you or your solicitor.
If your civil partner does not return the form, it may eventually
be necessary to arrange for another set of the documents to be
served personally unless you can prove in some other way that they
have received the petition and accompanying documents from the
court. This may for example be done by a process server (usually
a private detective) giving it to them personally.
Conditional Dissolution Order
If your civil partner agrees to the dissolution going ahead,
you can then swear a statement confirming that everything in the
dissolution petition is true, whether anything in the meantime
has changed and so on. With that statement, you can apply for the
conditional order. There is no fee at that stage The district judge
will then look at your dissolution papers and if the judge agrees
that you are entitled to a dissolution, the court will set a date
for the formal pronouncement of the conditional order, which may
be a week to a month or so after the district judge has approved
your dissolution. This is only the first dissolution order and
you remain civil partners until the final order.
Final Order
You can apply for the final order six weeks
after the date of the pronouncement of the conditional order. There
is another fee of £40 for that application. The court should
process that application within a week or so, but it often takes
longer.
In all, the dissolution can take as little as four to six months
from start to finish. However, it can take a lot longer if either
or both of you delay in taking particular steps during the proceedings,
or if there are problem with the court.
Finances
The court will not automatically look at any
issues surrounding maintenance, pensions or capital division, even
if these claims are made in the dissolution petition, which is customary.
If you think that there is no way that you will be able to come to
an agreement on finances, you may want to get the court involved
at an early stage. There may be other reasons, such as the need for
immediate maintenance or an order to freeze a bank account. You can
start the financial court proceedings on the same day that you start
your dissolution at court or you could wait and start them at any
other time during your dissolution proceedings or even after the
final order.
If you come to an agreement, the court can approve that agreement
and make an order reflecting it. This will give both of you
security that there is no come-back in case one of you changes
your mind. The court does not automatically rubber-stamp any
agreement, but in most cases the judges approve the agreement
reached. The earliest the courts can approve an agreement is
after the conditional order has been made. Therefore, if you
want the security of a court order, you may want to consider
starting a dissolution earlier rather than wait for two or
five years’ separation.
A solicitor can draft the order for you and explain to you what other papers
need to be send to the court. There are no set forms for the order, although
solicitors have standard precedents for most parts of the agreement.
If it comes to court proceedings, the way the English courts
deal with finances on the dissolution of a civil partnership
is very similar to how they deal with finances on divorce. See
ancillary relief.
Children of Civil Partners
The
effect of registering as civil partners will put a civil partner
who is not a biological parent in the same position as a step-parent.
On termination, where only one partner, the biological parent,
has what is known as ‘parental
responsibility’ (enabling him or her to make major
decisions regarding the child’s upbringing) the other
civil partner can acquire parental responsibility in a
number of ways i.e.
-
By agreement – this
will usually be in the form of the parties signing a prescribed
legal form whereby the biological parent with parental responsibility
consents to parental responsibility
for the other partner.
-
By order of the court
It should be understood that the parties do not need to wait
until the relationship is likely to be terminated before
applying for parental responsibility. This can be done on
registration or any time after.
In addition to the above the
non-biological parent can also apply to the court for parental
responsibility ‘without
leave’ where he or she has previously been obliged
to apply to the court for an order that the child resides
(lives) or has contact with him or her. As a consequence
of these provisions, future arrangements for any child
will be an important issue to be considered by registered
civil partners. Developing a good relationship between
parents and co-parents after separation will remain an
important goal and couples will be encouraged to work towards
this. Mediation will be encouraged and this may become
an increasingly important route to resolving disputes concerning
children for civil partners in particular.
back to top